Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Wise Ass FaustianSlip23/Female/Japan Recent Activity Deviant for 4 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 28 Deviations
41 Comments
824 Pageviews

DA Can Officially Get Bent.

Thu Jun 1, 2006, 11:10 PM
I don't think I have all that many people look at my work, so I don't expect this to be a very big deal, but in case anyone comes looking and wonders why nothing's here, I'm seriously considering deleting my artwork in response to the May 31st Community Development newsletter. I've related most of my issues with this in the actual thread for that newsletter, but I'll summarise them here:

• I find it incredibly hypocritical for the same administration trumpeting themselves as "protecting freedom of expression" to be engaging in rampant censorship (right after the announcement about allowing Nazi ideology on the site, in fact) by employing a hugely broad definition of "pornography" in deciding what and whom to ban from the site.

• I find it insulting to my intelligence that the same people engaging in censorship of plenty of other stuff on this site expect me to believe that because they're making a big show of allowing Nazis to post hate art, they're now huge defenders of freedom of expression. No, actually, you're not. Anyone with a brain can figure out the disconnect between the moratorium on any art that might depict an erect penis or contain overly-erotic prose and then saying that you support freedom of expression for everyone, even Nazis. Don't piss on my leg and tell me it's raining- all this says is that Nazis get more consideration than erotic artists. It's hardly proof of some noble support for all free speech.

• As a Jew, I don't feel that I can in good conscience support a website that employs this kind of moral relativism. Were all erotic art permitted, I wouldn't be so angry about the apparent welcoming of Nazi art (though there is some dispute over whether that's what this actually is, due in part to the vagueness and poor wording of the Community Development mail in question), but the censorship of other, specific kinds of artwork makes this allowance of hate art a very clear, very specific exception to the rules, and I don't think it's unreasonable to ask why. Given that no one has been able to offer any kind of satisfactory explanation (i.e. one not based wholly in the fallacious idea that hate art and explict erotic art are "totally different" and have nothing to do with each other), I'm finding a picture being painted of those running this site that is not, to me, terribly admirable or flattering.

• I've read some comments saying, in essence, "Oh, just stay and use DA for your own purposes, don't worry about the admin's idiocy," and "Well, my friends are here, so I'll stick around." I can understand both (particularly in light of the fact that those with paid subscriptions can't get their money back- convenient for an administration who pays very little attention, it seems, to the wants, needs or opinions of its paying customers), but there's a problem: what impetus does the administration have to change if, despite all of this talk, no one bothers to hold them accountable for their actions? This isn't the first time the administration have gone the route of masturbatory self-congratulation in the wake of a ridiculous decision, at the same time demonstrating a complete disregard for the intelligence of the people paying to use their site. If no one bothers to express displeasure and follow through (i.e. with monetary consequences, which are what usually make things more clearly understood), what is the likelihood that better, more even-handed decisions will be made in the future? I see the chances as being very small.

deviantID

No deviantID yet.

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: Japan
  • Interests: Tinkering with Photoshop, writing, travel... anything to forestall the brain rot, really.
  • Favourite band or musician: The Beatles
  • Favourite genre of music: Rock and/or oldies.
  • Favourite poet or writer: George Orwell
  • Favourite photographer: Matthew Brady
  • Favourite style of art: Anything interesting.
  • Operating System: Mac OSX
  • MP3 player of choice: They'll pry my iPod from my cold, dead hands. And maybe not even then.
  • Wallpaper of choice: At present, my Hugh Jackman/Boy From Oz one. Mmm.
  • Skin of choice: Watercolor Cherry, via Shapeshifter.
  • Favourite game: Super Mario Bros. 3. Old skool, and all.
  • Favourite gaming platform: XBox
  • Favourite cartoon character: Either Kyle from South Park or Lisa Simpson.
  • Personal Quote: I believe in cynicism with a smile.
  • Tools of the Trade: Dumb luck.

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconfractalmbrown:
I saw your comments on one of the recent news posts, and I must say I appreciate your intellect and insight. I'm adding you to my devwatch. :D

--
Heh.
:iconyuehan:
So....
You like Hugh Jackman, huh?

:O_o:

--
If you have to :eatshit: at least :brushteeth:
:iconyuehan:
By the way, Super Mario 3 iz thee best game ever....

--
If you have to :eatshit: at least :brushteeth:
:iconyuehan:
Your comment to the most recent Community Development report hit the donkey square in the shoes, as one might say. Tip o' the hat, to directing some reason towards the stuffi-puffi.

...

..

:-?

--
If you have to :eatshit: at least :brushteeth:
:iconbloo-kaonashi1:
Do you know any Japanese harajuku girls?
:iconfaustianslip:
Not a one- I live about four hours from Tokyo by shinkansen.

--
"[English] is a completely promiscuous language- it'll go to bed with anything."
- Professor Terry Dolan, University College Dublin
:iconbloo-kaonashi1:
Hello!I think your art is really nice and I love Japanese culture!
:iconrevohexe:
Thanks for the add!

--
The smart one has spoken. :dizzy:

Site Map